This post contains affiliate links. Please see our disclosure policy.
Mastering the 10 Commandments for the Best Big Green Egg Cheeseburger provides a way for you to produce spectacular results. You may think that owning a ceramic grill automatically guarantees a delicious meal. However, you should follow specific techniques to elevate your cook from good to world-class. This process ensures that every component of the burger works in harmony with the intense heat of the charcoal. The inspiration for this post started after I read a recent article by Anthony Bourdain. His list of simple rules departs from the modern trend of massive, over-stacked burgers. Because these rules focus on the essentials, they are the most effective method for true quality.
To achieve the best results, you must put these ten simple rules into practice on your grill. You should view this guide as the definitive way to honor the integrity of the beef. This technique provides a way for you to master the crust while maintaining a juicy interior. You will find that these commandments create a burger that is both nostalgic and sophisticated. Now, you should sit back and grab an ice-cold Stella Artois while you learn my methods. Because the spirit of the original Big Green Egg Cheeseburger Throwdown lives on, you are ready to cook. Once you fire up the lump charcoal, you will understand why these rules remain sacred for the backyard pitmaster.
Table of Contents
- First commandment: Thou shall keep it simple
- Second commandment: Thou shall use a potato bun
- Third commandment: Thou shall use “a hunk of well-ground, good-quality Beef”
- Fourth commandment: Thou shall use processed meltable cheese
- Fifth commandment: Thou shall be able to eat the burger with one hand
- Sixth commandment: Thou shall keep things symmetrical
- Seventh commandment: Thou shall not use condiments outside of ketchup and mayo (if you insist)
- Eighth commandment: Thou shall keep clean while eating
- Ninth commandment: Thou shall consider bacon… maybe.
- Tenth commandment: Thou shall not have a burger that’s difficult to eat
- People Also Ask (PAA)
- Big Green Egg Cheeseburger: The 10 Commandments Method Recipe
Get My NEW Book
The Ultimate Big Green Egg Cookbook
First commandment: Thou shall keep it simple
Mastering a simple cheeseburger is not as easy as it sounds. You should focus on the very important question of whether you are truly making the burger better. This process provides a way for you to resist the urge to build a massive monster burger. You will find that fighting this urge is hard in the modern age of food photography. Because a simple cheeseburger must stand on its own, it requires a higher level of technical skill. You should view this restraint as a professional-grade art worth mastering. To achieve the best results, you must prioritize the quality of the beef over excessive toppings. This technique ensures that your Big Green Egg Cheeseburgers deliver a sophisticated and balanced flavor. Once you master the basics, you will understand why simplicity remains the ultimate goal for the backyard pitmaster.
Second commandment: Thou shall use a potato bun
Mastering the starch for your meal is a no-brainer as potato buns are the best thing to happen to burgers since sliced cheese! You should view the Martin’s Potato Roll as a mechanical necessity because its pillowy texture allows the bread to compress without disintegrating. This process ensures that the bun absorbs the savory drippings from the Buddha Burger Blend without becoming a soggy mess. You will find that the high sugar content allows for a quick, professional-grade toast on the hot cast iron. Because a dense artisanal bun can cause the toppings to slide, this soft alternative remains the most effective method for maintaining a one-handed grip. You must lightly butter the roll to create a golden-brown barrier against the condiments. This technique provides a way for the sauces to sit on the surface rather than soaking into the bread.
Third commandment: Thou shall use “a hunk of well-ground, good-quality Beef”
Sounds obvious but you can find yourself lost with possibilities. When all else fails, grab the 80/20 blend of ground beef at your local grocery story as you want the meat to have a lot of fat. For this cook, I used a custom blend of brisket, short rib, and hanger steak. Once you have a custom blend of ground beef like this you will never go back!
Fourth commandment: Thou shall use processed meltable cheese
This one takes a lot of trial and error to learn because the tendency is to overcomplicate the burger with fancy cheeses like gouda, blue, etc. Using a processed cheese like American Cheese produces superior cheese melting every single time!
Fifth commandment: Thou shall be able to eat the burger with one hand
Is not as easy as it sounds. You must consider things like meat to bun ratio, single patty vs. multiple patties, toppings, etc. Having the ability to construct your burger so it can be eaten with one hand allows the other hand to do something useful (like drink a beer!)
Sixth commandment: Thou shall keep things symmetrical
Is key when constructing your burger. You want the experience to be consistent with every bite allowing the person eating to have the full impact of the flavors you put together.
Seventh commandment: Thou shall not use condiments outside of ketchup and mayo (if you insist)
Is a tough one for me. First of all, a burger isn’t a burger without mayonnaise so I do indeed insist. However, the measure of a truly good burger is one where you do not need any condiments and the flavor of the meat, cheese, bun, and toppings do all the work.
Eighth commandment: Thou shall keep clean while eating
Is one that is easily met if you have followed the previous seven commandments. When you start adding a fried egg, chili, etc. to your burger it is nearly impossible to stay clean.
Ninth commandment: Thou shall consider bacon… maybe.
Well, I can assure you removing the “maybe” is always a good idea because bacon makes everything better. Just remember balance is the key. If you add bacon do so in a way that gives you a bacon bite with every bite you take of the burger.
Tenth commandment: Thou shall not have a burger that’s difficult to eat
Is an easy one to achieve if you have followed the nine commandments preceding this one. In other words, no knives and forks with your burger.
Mastering the High-Heat Cast Iron Sear
Mastering the perfect crust on a burger requires you to embrace the intense thermal mass of a cast iron insert within the Big Green Egg. You should preheat your grill to a steady 600°F with the cast iron griddle or skillet positioned directly over the hot lump charcoal. This process provides a way for the metal to absorb and radiate a consistent, high-intensity heat that mimics a professional steakhouse broiler. You will find that this setup is the most effective method for achieving a deep, mahogany sear without overcooking the center of the meat. Because the cast iron creates a solid barrier against the direct flames, it prevents flare-ups while ensuring that every inch of the Buddha Burger Blend develops a savory bark.
To achieve the best results, you must work quickly to maintain moisture during the high-heat cook. You should place the seasoned burgers on the screaming hot surface and sear them for exactly two minutes with the dome closed. This technique ensures that your Big Green Egg Cheeseburgers develop a uniform crust that locks in the rich fats. You will find that flipping the burgers at the two-minute mark is the most reliable way to maintain a perfect medium-rare interior. Because the residual heat of the cast iron continues to work after the flip, you should immediately add the cheese and close the dome. This process provides a way for the cheese to liquefy while the crust sets perfectly. Once the cheese is melted, you should pull the burgers from the heat to rest for a professional-grade finish.
The Boiled and Grilled Bacon Technique
Mastering the perfect bacon topper for a Big Green Egg Cheeseburger requires you to rethink the traditional frying method. You should begin by boiling your thick-cut bacon in a shallow pan of water until it reaches a tender, pliable consistency. This process provides a way for the rendering of the heavy fats to occur without the risk of scorching the delicate meat. You will find that this professional-grade technique is the most effective method for ensuring that the bacon remains succulent and easy to bite through. Because boiled bacon has already released much of its excess grease, it is less likely to cause massive flare-ups when it finally hits the high-heat environment of the Big Green Egg.
To achieve the best results, you must move the par-boiled bacon directly onto the elevated grate or the cast iron surface once the water has evaporated. You should grill the strips for approximately two to three minutes per side to develop a smoky, mahogany char that complements the Buddha Burger Blend. This technique ensures that your Big Green Egg Cheeseburgers feature a topping that is both crispy on the edges and melt-in-your-mouth tender. You will find that the intense charcoal flavor penetrates the pre-softened meat more effectively than raw bacon. Because the bacon is already fully cooked from the boiling stage, you should focus solely on achieving the desired level of “snap” and smoke infusion. Once the bacon is gilded and fragrant, you should set it aside on a warm plate to prepare for the final assembly of the ultimate cheeseburger.
Final Thoughts: 10 Commandments for the Best Big Green Egg Cheeseburger
Mastering the 10 Commandments for the Best Big Green Egg Cheeseburger provides a way for you to transform a simple backyard staple into a professional-grade culinary event. You should view every element from the Buddha Burger Blend to the toasted potato roll as a critical component of a balanced machine. This process ensures that the high-heat environment of the ceramic grill works in harmony with your technical skills to produce a superior result. You will find that these commandments act as your primary guardrails for maintaining the integrity of the beef while achieving a world-class crust. Because a truly great cheeseburger relies on the quality of its foundation, your commitment to the 600°F cast iron sear remains the most effective method for success.
To achieve the best results, you must trust the simplicity of the ingredients and the precision of your timing. You should resist the urge to overcomplicate the toppings and instead focus on the succulent, charcoal-infused flavor of the premium fats. This technique ensures that your Big Green Egg Cheeseburgers deliver a sophisticated experience that guests will find both nostalgic and elevated. Because the spirit of the original “Throwdown” lives on in every perfectly melted slice of American cheese, you are now equipped to win every backyard battle. Once the burgers have rested and the juices have redistributed, you should serve them immediately to capture the peak of the grilling experience.
People Also Ask (PAA)
- What is the best ground beef blend for a Big Green Egg burger? You should prioritize a custom 80/20 lean-to-fat ratio by blending beef chuck, brisket, and short rib. This process provides a way for the rich marbling to baste the meat from the inside out. Because the Big Green Egg generates intense heat, high fat content ensures the patty stays moist.
- How long do you cook a burger on the Big Green Egg at 600°F? To achieve a perfect medium-rare center, you should grill the patties for exactly two minutes per side on cast iron. This technique ensures that the exterior develops a deep mahogany crust while the interior remains tender. You will discover that closing the dome during the sear is essential for maintaining a consistent temperature. Once the flip occurs, you should immediately add the cheese to allow it to liquefy.
- Why should I use a cast iron skillet on the Big Green Egg? You should understand that cast iron provides a superior thermal mass that traditional stainless steel grates cannot match. This process creates a solid contact point that results in a professional-grade sear across the entire patty. You will find that the cast iron also prevents flare-ups from rendering fat. Because the metal retains heat effectively, it allows you to cook multiple batches without losing the necessary temperature.
- Can I use different buns instead of potato rolls? While you can use other options, you should view the Martin’s Potato Roll as a mechanical necessity for a one-handed burger. This technique ensures that the soft bread compresses without disintegrating under the weight of the juices. Because the potato bun toasts quickly, it remains the definitive choice for the 10 Commandments.
Big Green Egg Cheeseburger: The 10 Commandments Method
Equipment
- 1 BGE Half Moon Cast Iron Plancha
Ingredients
- 1.5 pounds Buddha Burger Blend, 80/20 mix of Brisket, Short Rib, and Chuck
- 4 Martin’s Potato Rolls , Commandment #2
- 4 slices Processed American Cheese , Commandment #4
- 2 tbsp SPG rub, Salt, Pepper, Garlic
- 1 pound Thick-cut Bacon, boiled until tender, then grilled on plancha
- Ketchup and Mayonnaise , to taste
Instructions
- BGE Setup: Preheat the Big Green Egg to 600°F and place a cast iron insert (griddle or skillet) directly on the grate to stabilize.
- Prep: Form the custom beef blend into 6oz patties with a gentle touch, ensuring they are slightly wider than the potato rolls.
- Season: Coat both sides of the patties generously with the SPG rub just before they hit the cast iron.
- The Sear: Place the patties on the screaming hot cast iron and sear for 2 minutes with the dome closed to develop a heavy crust.
- The Flip: Turn the burgers over and immediately top each with a slice of American cheese and the prepared "Pig Patty" bacon.
- The Melt: Close the dome for an additional 2 minutes, allowing the cheese to liquefy and the center to reach a perfect medium-rare.
- Assembly: Place the patties onto the potato rolls and add minimal condiments to ensure the burger remains a one-handed affair.
Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.
