This post contains affiliate links. Please see our disclosure policy.

There is nothing quite like the flavor of homemade roast beef, especially when it starts with a beautifully marbled piece of American Wagyu. The top round comes from the Round Primal Cut and is home to inexpensive cuts of meat often used for roasts, London Broil, or ground beef. As the weather warms up in the Springtime, I wanted to find a way to honor this cut with a method that highlights its natural tenderness. Learning how to make roast beef on a Traeger grill is the perfect way to turn this approachable cut into a centerpiece for your next gathering.

What is better than a perfectly cooked roast beef for sandwiches or served on its own with a nice selection of cheeses? This recipe for homemade top round roast beef could not be any easier to make, and you should feel confident to try this on your own. By using the precision of a pellet grill, you ensure a consistent medium-rare finish that rivals any high-end deli. Now sit back, grab an ice cold PBR, and enjoy this post on How to Make the Best Roast Beef on a Traeger Grill: Deli-Style Recipe.

How to Make the Best Roast Beef on a Traeger Grill: Deli-Style Recipe

The Cut: Why Top Round is the King of Roast Beef
Step 1: The Seasoning
Step 2: The High-Heat Cast Iron Sear
Step 3: The Low-and-Slow Smoke
Step 4: Monitoring the Internal Temperature
Step 5: The Essential Rest and Cooling Period
Step 6: Slicing and Serving
Storage and Suggested Uses
How to Make the Best Roast Beef on a Traeger Grill: Deli-Style Recipe

Get My NEW Book

The Ultimate Big Green Egg Cookbook

order now

The Cut: Why Top Round is the King of Roast Beef

Choosing the right cut of meat is the most important decision you will make before you ever fire up the grill. A high-quality top round provides a great confidence booster for any cook. The marbling alone tells you that the meat will be delicious no matter how you cook it. While many people reach for expensive loin cuts, the top round offers the perfect balance of lean muscle and fine intramuscular fat that defines a classic deli-style roast.

The top round comes from the inner portion of the hind leg, known as the Round Primal. Because this muscle supports the weight of the animal, it is naturally lean and full of deep beefy flavor that stands up well to wood-fired smoke. This cut is the best choice for roast beef because its uniform shape allows for even cooking and consistent, beautiful slices across the grain. You can typically find a high-quality top round at a local butcher or in the specialty meat case of most well-stocked grocers. Once you have sourced a well-marbled piece of beef, you are ready to focus on this recipe for delicious homemade roast beef.

Step 1: The Seasoning

Creating a bold crust is essential for a roast that will eventually be sliced thin for sandwiches. By using a high-quality dry rub, you enhance the natural beefy notes of the top round without overpowering the wood-fired flavor from the Traeger. This combination of seasonings ensures a savory exterior that complements the tender, juicy interior of the beef.

Start out by adding Kosher salt, coarse black pepper, and garlic powder to a small mixing bowl for a classic DIY beef rub. Whisk the ingredients together in equal parts until they are well combined and the mixture is uniform. If you prefer a pre-made option, popular brands like Meat Church Holy Cow, Hardcore Carnivore Black, or Traeger Beef Rub offer excellent savory profiles that pair perfectly with this cut. Pat the top round roast completely dry with paper towels to ensure the seasoning adheres properly to the surface of the meat. Apply your chosen rub generously to all sides of the roast, pressing the spices firmly into the beef so they stay in place during the searing process. Because the salt needs time to penetrate the muscle fibers, let the seasoned roast sit at room temperature for at least fifteen minutes before you head to the stove.

Step 2: The High-Heat Cast Iron Sear

Establishing a deep, caramelized crust is a critical step that a pellet grill simply cannot achieve on its own at lower temperatures. By using a cast iron pan, you create a professional-grade sear that locks in moisture and adds a savory “bark” to the exterior of the beef. This process provides the essential texture and flavor contrast that separates a great homemade roast beef from a mediocre one.

Preheat a large cast iron pan over medium-high heat until it is hot and just beginning to smoke. Add a small amount of high-smoke-point oil, such as avocado or grapeseed oil, to coat the bottom of the pan. Once the pan is ready, sear each side of the top round for about two minutes per side. Use heavy-duty tongs to hold the roast upright so you can also sear the ends and smaller edges. Because the goal is only to build a crust and not to cook the interior, work quickly to ensure the center remains raw. Remove the beef from the pan and place it on a clean tray once every surface is beautifully browned and ready for the Traeger.

Step 3: The Low-and-Slow Smoke

Transitioning the seared beef to the pellet grill allows you to infuse the meat with deep, wood-fired flavor without overcooking the exterior. By maintaining a low and steady temperature, you ensure the interior of the top round reaches a perfect edge-to-edge pink. This process provides the tender texture and smoky aroma that define a high-quality homemade roast beef.

Setup your Traeger Timberline to 225°F using your favorite wood pellets for a long, consistent smoke. For this cook, I used cherry pellets because they provide a mild sweetness and a beautiful mahogany color to the finished crust. Once the grill has reached the target temperature, place the seared top round directly onto the center of the grill grate. Close the lid and allow the meat to smoke undisturbed while the internal temperature slowly climbs. Because the top round is a lean muscle, monitoring the heat is critical to prevent the roast from becoming tough or dry.

Step 4: Monitoring the Internal Temperature

Precision is the most important factor when you are learning how to make roast beef on a Traeger grill. By using an integrated meat probe, you eliminate the guesswork and ensure that the lean top round does not overcook. This process provides a consistent result, allowing you to pull the meat at the exact moment it reaches your desired level of doneness.

When the grill is up to temp and ready, place the seared top round inside with the probe inserted into the thickest part of the meat. Set the probe to monitor for a 125°F internal temperature, which is the ideal pull temp for a rare roast. Because the beef will continue to cook slightly once you remove it from the heat, pulling at this stage ensures a perfect medium-rare finish. Close the lid and let the Traeger work its magic while the wood-fired smoke penetrates the seared crust. Once the alarm sounds, you are ready to move on to the most difficult part of the entire cook—the wait.

Step 5: The Essential Rest and Cooling Period

Patience is the final ingredient in mastering how to make roast beef on a Traeger grill. By allowing the meat to rest properly, you ensure the juices redistribute throughout the muscle fibers instead of spilling out onto the cutting board. This process provides the tender, succulent texture that defines a professional deli-style roast.

After the top round reaches the target temperature, pull the roast from the grill and place it on a clean carving board or tray. Allow the beef to rest at room temperature for at least one hour before placing it in the fridge. Because the meat is so lean, this gradual cooling period helps the exterior crust set while the interior remains incredibly moist. Once the roast has cooled completely, wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and chill it overnight to ensure the best possible results. This overnight rest is the secret to getting those paper-thin, deli-style slices the next day.

Step 6: Slicing and Serving

Achieving the perfect slice is the final step in mastering how to make roast beef on a Traeger grill. After the beef has been in the fridge for several hours, it is time to slice and serve your masterpiece. By chilling the meat thoroughly, you firm up the muscle fibers, which allows for much cleaner cuts without the meat tearing or shredding. This process provides that classic deli appearance that makes homemade roast beef so visually appealing.

For the most authentic deli-style experience, using a dedicated electric meat slicer is the best option for achieving paper-thin results. Because a slicer maintains a consistent thickness, you can pile the meat high on sandwiches for a professional look and texture. In the photos for this cook, I used a very sharp carving knife, which naturally produces slightly thicker slices. While these thicker cuts are incredibly hearty and delicious, they offer a more rustic, “Sunday roast” feel compared to a commercial slicer. If you are using a knife, ensure it is freshly honed and aim for the thinnest slices possible by cutting against the grain.

Storage and Suggested Uses

Once you have enjoyed your initial serving, proper storage is key to maintaining the quality of your wood-fired roast beef. Place any remaining meat in an airtight container or a vacuum-sealed bag and keep it in the refrigerator for up to five days. Because this beef is so lean and flavorful, it remains tender even when served cold the next day. This homemade version is far superior to any pre-packaged alternative and contains zero hidden preservatives.

The Ultimate Sandwich: Pile thin slices onto a toasted baguette with provolone cheese and a side of au jus for a world-class French Dip.
The Protein Salad: Toss chilled slices over a bed of arugula with shaved parmesan and a lemon vinaigrette for a light, healthy lunch.
The Roast Beef Platter: Serve thicker slices alongside a selection of sharp cheddar, horseradish cream, and crusty bread for an easy entertaining board.

Save Pin Print

No ratings yet